Entry № 003_NEW · Verified Apr 2026
About
Emmett's more polished West Village sibling on Grove Street adds Italian plates and a fuller drinks programme to the Chicago deep-dish format, giving the format a grown-up dining room to inhabit.
Sophisticated hangout dispensing boozy drinks & Italian plates, including Chicago-inspired pizzas.
Editors’ notes
“As a pizza snob this place is definitely in my top 3. The thin crust is extremely unique with a crack like crust lightly sprinkled with sesame seeds. The hot honey girl (don't quote me) is my favorite. The deep fried olives and homemade potato are delicious. The rustic vibe compliments the food for a good chill spot. H…”
“Couldn’t get a reservation, but walked in at 5:15pm straight to a table of 2. Restaurant quickly filled up in the next half hour, very popular spot. They have happy hour at the bar for $9 martinis and the bar was full 15 minutes after they opened. Truly lovely ambiance, perfectly dimmed lights. Pizzas massive and flav…”
“This is a popular hangout neighborhood place with a warm and cozy vibe. Their chicago style thin crust jalapeño pepperoni pizza was crispy, soft and uniquely 😋 delicious. I also love their savory chicken parm sliders with gooey melted cheese. A great selection of yummy cocktails and desserts led to a great ending of a…”
“This was one of the best pizzas I’ve had in New York! We ordered two appetizers and one pizza for two people, and it was more than enough food. We got the Hot Papi pizza — and if you like spicy, you’re in for a real treat. The flavors were bold, the crust was perfect, and the heat was just right. Can’t wait to come bac…”